***atif VS gohar***

6543 views 99 replies
Reply to Topic
Frankenstein

Age: 124
Total Posts: 6323
Points: 0

Location:
Faroe Islands, Faroe Islands
hye,

public yeh kia chal rha hai who the heck is this gohar atif kay saray ganay khraab kiay ja raha hai and baikaaar vdo's release kar raha hai...yaara koi batao what wid this thing...i heard kay both r the members of the same group lakin when i saw the credits and band members on the cd of ATIf which is jal paree wahan tu he dint give a crap about gohar...aur gohar atif kay compositions aur lyrics bari hadddharmi kay sath gaye chalay ja raha hai...dont know atif is on the right ya kay gohar...kis ko isss game ka pata ho tu share it wid me
Posted 12 Sep 2004

bhai jaan its other way around atif ne gohar ke sari compositions and songs apnay name se release kiay hein and to avoid copyrights law us ne songs ke nam tak change kardiay hein is liay gohar ne atif ke songs ki wat nahi lagaye atif ne lagaye hai and let me tell u one thing ke from this album atif aslam kisi song ki video nahi bana sakta other wise he ill be arrested on denying the copyrights law cuz these all songs belongs to original JAL which comprises gohar mumtaz,farhan,shazy thats it so jus forget the atif's crap and listen to the original JAL.
Posted 12 Sep 2004

ahh aint it crazy......atif has already made the video of AADAT and working on the next video...i have his cell # if will ask him kay kia chakkar hai...wasay atif looks innocent aisay kar tu naheee sakta..but lets uncover the fake
Posted 13 Sep 2004

wasay ur right..atif kay album main bheegi yaadain hai and gohar has its lamhay...maloom nahee kia controversy hai
Posted 13 Sep 2004

aisay ho bhi sakta hai bcoz i suppose pakistan main copyrights ka matlab hota hai rights to copy
Posted 13 Sep 2004

Ashii says
who is atif
whi s gohar
Posted 13 Sep 2004

gohar aur atif main un ki web site jaltheband.com ki owner ship ka mamla bhi court main hay
Posted 13 Sep 2004

lost prophets said:

aisay ho bhi sakta hai bcoz i suppose pakistan main copyrights ka matlab hota hai rights to copy




ur absolutely right dude and u know guyz ke ali zafar ka channo song was copied by a new singer awish and he also released that with changed lyrics and it sounds JANAM KI ANKH MEIN EK NASHA HAI but his album was dead flopp so now u can imagine where the hell is copyright law
Posted 13 Sep 2004

SALL said:

who is atif
whi s gohar




atif is the guy jis ne song gaya tha ADAT and gohar is the one who played the guitars in that song he was the musician.
Posted 13 Sep 2004

ya i heard janam ki ankh main what a horsesh*t that was by AAVISH RABBANI...even the composition was almost the same ..wasay i heard that ali zafar himself copied that song from some oldy goldy number
Posted 14 Sep 2004

TeenTracker said:

gohar aur atif main un ki web site jaltheband.com ki owner ship ka mamla bhi court main hay



i dint know it...abhi yeh bhi pata chala that website is also disputed
Posted 14 Sep 2004

fahadhabib says
Hello there...

Jal's New Single "Aik Din Ayega " is CRAP.. and make no sense... i found it on http://www.itspakistan.net/music/artist.aspx?aid=15.. a waste of time to listen...

Enjoy anyway!
Posted 14 Sep 2004

another dumb atif fan i guess
Posted 14 Sep 2004

ya i agree charizmatic
Posted 15 Sep 2004

BadShaH1 says
LOL charizmatic yar tumhein jo khabr milee
uss pe yaqeen kerke bheth gaye!!
ho sakta hey its the other way round??

dekho. Atif has a gr8 voice
and a Gohar is an amazing guitarist.
and their song LAMHEY is not bad either.

but the two go together the best. i say and wish they come back together.
and anyone can say U a dumb Goher fan too
Posted 15 Sep 2004

hi salamz to every 1 ... i waz not uzin net 4 a long time .. but jab se main ne yeh naya topic gohar vs atif uffff maze ka topic banaya hai ...
first of oll i should ssay u thx for makin sum new kinda stuff'z topicz ...
uss k baad gohar yaar uss ne to acche khasse ganay ki melody kharab kardi ..... atif ki awaz bhi best hai .....
main to kehti hoon k east or west atif iz da best ...
yeh hai k atif bohat massom lagta hai yaar i think k main to atif ki jaga kisi aur gohar aur uss k memberz ko nahi de sakti ... mere pass atif ke saare ganay hain pluged or unplugged n u koe wat i think gohar ko koi aur ganay bana ne chaiye ... aacccha main ne yeh bhi suna hai k atif jo ganay ga raha hai wo sab gohar ne likha the .... i dun koe wat else man .

gohar aur atif acche frenz the magar gohr k bhai ki waja se bhi in k beech main larai hoi ... aur jab main ne gohar ki video dekhi to basss i m damn out wid gohar ..................

hey hi atif I LOV U !

hey atif u should make ur new style ..... ! hopin da good 4 u !
Posted 15 Sep 2004

ahan same ager wo saath aye to bohat accha response mil sakta hai .....

       ATIF N GOHAR B FRENZ ONCE AGAIN PLZZ
             HEY ATIF U SHOULD LISTEN 2 ME !
Posted 15 Sep 2004

ya i agree wid u ppl atif ka style gohar say fit hai no doubts on it...lakin if he copied the songs of gohar tu he aint good for nothing....yaaar real real hee hai...acha ho ya bura...agar atif copied gohar songs..gohar ka carrier to gaya na...it will take atleast 6 or more months to make new..anywayz
ppl u shud hear bheegi yaadain unplugged.its awesome..wasay saman i have also got the unplugged versions
Posted 16 Sep 2004

iam experimenting on this lets see its works ya nahe
Posted 16 Sep 2004

failed
Posted 16 Sep 2004

iam gonna make another try...as u pll must have heard try try again n go to spain

Posted 16 Sep 2004

see ppl what i got

Posted 16 Sep 2004

Posted 16 Sep 2004

i really like the one cumin as follow

Posted 16 Sep 2004

see ive added colours to the post
Posted 16 Sep 2004

u ppl know another member joined the band ???? no !
then see this

Hello Fans,

We are proud to announce that the very talented Aamir (Shazi) has joined JAL as a bass player. He has been playing for 'Jupiters' for around four years and has also played for Shahzad Hameed Band. Lets all just welcome Shazi to the band and with addition to his efforts InshAllah you will get a better sound of JAL. Thanks for all your support.

Regards,
The Admin.
Posted 16 Sep 2004

here's the real story from the real guy goher...have a look n decide who's innocent..goher himself tells the story.so here it is:-

Dear lovely fans,
There were lot of controversies and rumors were spreading about jaL breaking up, so here I am to tell you. Officially what happened with jaL and will tell about some people who tried to spoil it and start it by creating some rumors about me. U have seen many cases of bands breaking up, but I am sure the whole music industry have never seen such a band who had only one song released and they break up. I want to tell u the truth and the reason behind it that why I kick Atif out of band and what was the reasons that forced me to do that.

As ppl from PICS know since when I have been singing Aadat without even the existence of Atif. So no point in proving anything else.. J

That was August 15th 2003 when we ”JAL” had a contract offer with the biggest cellular company of Pakistan and Fakher-Alam was the consultant for that concerning company and they want to meet us immediately in Islamabad for the contract terms and conditions. That day Atif came to me and said that we should have a manager who can talk about this and he said that my brother I is the manager of jaL from now to represent us. I frankly agreed with Atif and thought that he is Atif’s brother and doing that for the sake of the band . so I agreed and I , Atif and his brother Shahbaz Aslam went to meet them and that is the way this manager entered in the band but I had no idea that what’s his intentions were.! After a month, we got some offers for concerts, and I personally refer people to talk with shahbaz Aslam. With only one song , his brother has started claiming 80000 per concert. ( I think many people who are reading this post are witnesses for that). Some organizer talked to me again and said that are you people r in senses ??/ I mean after one song you people have gone mad and start thinking that you are a super star and bla bla.. so I told Atif once to talk to your brother and tell him that day will come when we will charge more then 80,000 and warned him that don’t claim this money again and start with some decent amount because at the start of jal, we need some exposure instead of money.. he said, “ BACHAY MUGHAY CALL KERTAY HEIN TOE I M SAYING THIS TO REFUSE THEM”… but then again he told the same amount to the people that jal will charge 80,000 and said me that people will agree on it . but in result we have lost 6 concerts in from the month of September to the start of November. Shahbaz didn’t show me any contract he was doing on behalf of Jal. After some days I saw one of the contracts and guess what? He mentioned that Shahbaz Aslam ( Atif’s brother) is the band member of jaL, ( I will show u the photo copy of that contract on internet ). I talked to Shahbz and asked him that why u mention your name in in the contract as band member and asked him that are you going to play drums. Guitar, bass guitar or will sing with your brother? , he replied I m just sort of a band member for u , I will work with u people , I will design the wardrobe for you people, I will direct your videos and will open a production house ( with the name blue) and then I will open a boutique. And will manage the band, and all the accounts of the band. he want to be a wanna be and want to do it through the channel of jal, matlab , director+designer+band member+band manager. And Atif has full l votes for his “BELOVED” brother , then my brother had a meeting with Shahbaz Aslam and discuss this thing and told him that this thing should be done by the professionals that is Professional Managers for the betterment of the exposure of jaL and u r watching field of interest through the band instead of making plans to buy the instruments for the band. but he said that this is my brother who is the vocalist in the band and Goher only writes and plays guitar and composes for the band and my brother is much dominant and Atif also said to me that u will not sing for the band and will only play. (Hello.. I made the band Hello)..I think they were really out of their minds. Anyways, I came up with a point and told Atif tha I wil not work with your greedy brother. Either its ur brother Shahbaz Aslam or me. And left his place. That was the time when the video of Aadat was going to launch and that was the time of happiness for the band because we already got success and appreciation from internet. But on the other hand , his brother was planning that how to get rid of Goher and how to promote his brother. In this process we got an offer for a concert in Al-hamra which was organized on 24th of January. And Atif called me at my place through a person and said that there is no more Shahbaz Aslam between us and come back and lets do the concert. I had a fight with my brother and I said to him that I want Goher who made picked me from college and made Aadat a big hit. And he made a condition that I will manage the Jal from now on. I said okie fine, i thought that I should believe in him as he is also a good friend of mine and if he is doing it for the sake of the band then I should also come back and rejoin to continue the gigs , just for the sake of the band, so I agreed with him and stared the jamz and he told me that we are doing that concert in 20000 Rs.. I never knew that behind this scene, Atif and his brother signed a deal with SADAF STEREO through Mekaal Hassan , and when Mekaal and Salman Elbert ask that where is Goher, then his brother replied that we were giving him some percentage and he did’nt agree on it so he left the band. ( this statement of Atif was being told to me by Mekaal Hasaan). but I had no idea whats going on. In those days I got a call from Ahmed Zakaria ( Manager operation ARY , THE MUSIK) for some performances for THE MUSIK channel and he wanted that jal should be there on with with noori, Karvaan and Fuzon.on the 22nd of January. I have talked to Atif about this and he asked me, Goher have u sign any deal with ARY ?,, I replied him with a smile that there is nothing like that , we are just going there for some Tv performances and ARY is sending us the tickets for it they said. I will think over it to go to ARY. And in that time we were doing our jamz for the concert in Al-Hamra on 24th of January and were pretty prepared for the concert , so I again asked to Atif to go with me to Ary and we should not miss that big chance for Tv coverage. He agreed, but then at the last moment. He said that I have an emergency so I m not going, ( just on the instruction of his brother ) because he knows that Atif is vocalist and Goher cannot go with out Atif,. I called Ahmed Zakaria and told him that Atif is not coming, if u want me then I will come on the behalf of the band and sing my two songs which I m singing in the album. Like Dilharay and another song. Ahmed said , okey come here and perform two songs as he told to everyone that Jal is coming and performing and this would be highly non-professional thing that once u commit with a channel and then refuse it at the last time. So I had to leave alone for Karachi and told them I will come back on 23rd and will do the concert on 24th in Alhamra,, here I will put an example about our Pakistani poilitics, when chief. Of Army staff was out of country and mr. Newaz shareef made a plan to remove him in the absense of pervaiz mussharaf and want the control of his Air Plane. I think in my case Atif Aslam is mr. Newaz shareef who wants everything and I had to rescue my self..
I went to ARY for recording. His brother who was calling ARY for 2 days and talking AS Atif, said that Goher came here without telling Atif, and u called the wrong person , and forcefully convinced them that Goher is a Secessionist in the band and Atif is the main guy of the band. (Hello .. I am the sessionist?) , when I went to Ary , I have now words what I have been through. They took the Airline tickets back and didn’t let me perform on the show. I was really shocked at that time because I never expected that from Atif and his brother that they will do that to make me out form the band. Ahmed Zakaria and Umer Sheikh are the witnesses of this matter as it all happened in ARY office. I really appreciate ARY especially Umer Shiekh’s wisdom & professionalism, the way he handled the matter. And When I called Atif form my cell and asked him what the hell are u doing by telling them that goher is a secessionist and I didn’t tell u about the ARY function. Toe he replied. I have to go , my cell battery is quite low.

My dear fans, I have to came back from Karachi and I was really pissed off at that time and not in a mood to do the concert on 24rth but I had to do it for the sake of the band. but when I went to Al-hamra, Atif and his brother Shahbaz Aslam has already told the organizers that if Goher will come then kick him off form Al Hamra as he is no more the band member, I tried to tell him that its my band and showed him some legal paper that they cannot perform without me they all were shocked but ultimately t the organizers had to do the concert because they have sold all the tickets and one of the organizer shazil told me that we will continue the concert because we have paid 50000 to jal’manager i.e. Shahbaz Aslam. I was like but Atif told me that u paid them 20000 for that concert. They said. No we have paid his manager 50000 for the concert. And when I asked him that to whom u paid that money. Show me the man , then that man was again his brother Shahbaz Aslam who was managing Jal on his own after the saying of Atif to me that he is out form the Jal. Shahbaz came and said that kick him out and he is not in the band. Atif picked my two guitar students(HAIDER and OMER) who knows all my song chords which I have composed and they did that concert with him. I think I have never seen the selfishness like this and Atif used them because for the songs he don’t have any other option other then haider and omer because we use to jam at the haider and omer’s place, and atif and shahbaz didn't let them know the reality and made them believe that goher is out of the band so that haider and omer who knew the songs chords could play for him. Haider and Omer were being misguided throughout.

The only reason that I kicked Atif is just because his selfishness which he has showed and the dishonesty and greed of his brother and his plan to kick me out from my own band.. Sorry my friends, After a one song, u should not behave like Michael Jackson. Mm I think Michael Jackson must have some self respect for him and honesty, better than Atif and his brother..

I can say more, but due to legal grounds I cannot.. and as to tell u all, my lawyers who is handling this now is one of the best law firms in our country and they are making sure that ppl associated with Atif and his brother whoever it maybe will pay a big price for this act.. so wait and see J..

And to all the organizers out there, don’t let atif promote jal as he cannot sing cover songs of jal.

From this day onward, all questions and queries regarding Jal will be asked and discussed by our OFFICIAL MANAGER “Khurram Bhai EP (Jilawatan)” so don’t hesitate to contact him…

Love you all for the support ………

Goher
Posted 16 Sep 2004

read it in installments ya phir save karkay baad main bcoz its lenghty but u shud read it..iam totally surprised by reading this so will u be
Posted 16 Sep 2004

goher i feel sorry for u lakin forget the past i wish u luck for the future
Posted 16 Sep 2004

emmm now wat to say MAN ......... itz just surprizin simply eyez openin !!!!!!!!!
Posted 16 Sep 2004

hey u got nice posterz of GOHAR he really lookz nice !! 4 gohar
Posted 16 Sep 2004

Reply to Topic