A Question about MGAQ "?"

1769 views 11 replies

Badal

Age: 124
Total Posts: 5612
Points: 0

Location:
Pakistan, Pakistan

Mirza Ghulam Ahmed Qadiani claimed:

"Mahdi is not anyone’s student... I swear that this is exactly my condition Nobody can prove that any human has taught me Quran or Hadith or Tafseer..." (Roohani Khazain Vol 14 p. 394 by Mirza Qadiani)

Here is the real screenshot from his book.

But he also wrote:

"When I was 6-7 years old a person teacher was employed for me who taught me Holy Quran and some farsi books and his name was Fazal Ilahi." (Roohani Khazain Vol 13. P. 180)

"At 10 years of age an Arabic Teacher was appointed for me whose name was Fazal Ahmed." (Roohani Khazain Vol 13. P. 180)

"When I was 17 -18 years of age I was educated by another Molvi Saheb whose name was Gul Ali Shah, who was appointed by my father in Qadian to teach me." (Roohani Khazain Vol 13. P. 180)

Here is the real screenshot from his book.

Regardles of whether he was a prophet or not, can such claims that were prooved false by himself be made by a prophet?

Posted 13 Jun 2005

Djeedja Shareef says

Djeedja Shareef

Age: 124
7107 days old here
Total Posts: 42
Points: 0

Location:
,

@badal

yaar ab rehne do. Anhazrat (saws) was ummi nabi, anparrh. but as he died, he could read and write somethings. he has learnt this from sahaba.

regardind Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Qadiani (as), as everybody could see, he just learnt the basics of arabic and as u might have laernt quran by a teacher, too, who must not a mufasser or muhaddis or a master of religion, but just a normal teacher, who is teaching u the basics, not the deep meanings of what behind the words is. the same are these teachers, they were not mufassir or muhaddis or something else, unknown persons.

on the other hand. as hazrat moosa (as) was called by Allah to be a nabi, he himself hesitated to be one and asked Allah, that he has killed one person. Allah ne nabi banana hai, nabi ne khud nabi nahi ban na.

on the other hand, we dont know, which book was written first. he wrote more than 82 books.

and on the other hand, do u give a quarantee, that if this question is replied satisfull, u will accept it? dont do the same practice as christians doing against islam, seraching the contradictions in quran and asking themselves, whether this religion is right or not.

first let us discuss about the basics.

is hazrat Isa (as) living or dead?
can there be a prophet (without any new law) or not?

inn massayel se to niklaiN pehle, aage ki baat bhi kar lete haiN.

Please read this note about my opinion

Posted 14 Jun 2005

Badal says

Badal

Age: 124
7224 days old here
Total Posts: 5612
Points: 0

Location:
Pakistan, Pakistan

What i tried to say in this topic becomes very obvious from your own books. Any person can understand it easily.

Djeedja Shareef said:
@badal

yaar ab rehne do. Anhazrat (saws) was ummi nabi, anparrh. but as he died, he could read and write somethings. he has learnt this from sahaba.

regardind Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Qadiani (as), as everybody could see, he just learnt the basics of arabic and as u might have laernt quran by a teacher, too, who must not a mufasser or muhaddis or a master of religion, but just a normal teacher, who is teaching u the basics, not the deep meanings of what behind the words is. the same are these teachers, they were not mufassir or muhaddis or something else, unknown persons.

"hamary Nabi (SAW) nay aur Nabiyoon ki tarah zahiri ilm kisi ustad say nahi parha, magar Hazrat isa aur Hazrat Mosa maktaboon main bethay thay" that is visible in the first screenshot, isnt it?

Now he claimed that unhoon nay bhi kisi ustad say ilm hasil nahi kiya (whether in depth or not, as our Prophet), jo kay unhoon nay khud hi ghalat sabit kar diya.

"aur Hazrat Isa nay aik yahoodi ustad say Toraat parhi thi" that is also visible in screenshot. He claimed that he is not like that, but he did studied Quran from a teacher, as he himself wrote.

Posted 14 Jun 2005

Badal says

Badal

Age: 124
7224 days old here
Total Posts: 5612
Points: 0

Location:
Pakistan, Pakistan

Djeedja Shareef said:
on the other hand, we dont know, which book was written first. he wrote more than 82 books.

Dont tell me that yaar. He started writing books from 1972 onwards (while he born on 1935, 37 years of age then) i can proove it from your own material, while he started studing Quran from a teacher at the age of 6/7.

Posted 14 Jun 2005

Djeedja Shareef says

Djeedja Shareef

Age: 124
7107 days old here
Total Posts: 42
Points: 0

Location:
,

@badal

itni beheass me jaanay ki zaroorat hi nahi, bhai jaan. aap mujhe kuch jawab de deN, main aap ko kuch jawab de deta huN. otherwise aap apni karte raheN main apni karta rehta huN. jiss type ke sawal aap kar rahe haiN, yeh to jaari raheN ge, i am sure, aap ne khud to koi kitaab nahi parrhi Mirza ghulam ahmad(as) ki. bass kahiN say aitrazat ka bundle utha laaye. so yeh to khatam nahi hone. inn ka jawab aap official website par talash kijiye.

pehle yeh bataye, waisay aap Mirza Ghulam Ahmad (AS) ki baat tasleem nahi karte, yeh ussatizah wali kioN tassleem kar li? phir agar tassleem ki bhi to baaqi kioN nahi tassleem karte?
phir yeh ke yeh sabit karna to aap par hai abhi lazim ke konse ustad se taleem hassil ki unhoN ne?
ab chotte scholloN me parrhanay wale ko bhi ustad hi kehte hain magar woh koi mana hua ustad thorra hi hota hai. ab aap idher bhi aik lafz "ustad" ko pakarr ke baith jaayen to kuch kiya nahi jasakta, bhai jaan.

"quran aur hadees me kissi ustad ka shagird nahi hoga" means for me, kissi maane hue zamanay ke ustad ka shagird nahi hoga.

ab maulvi fazal ilahi, sahib ko koi nahi janta ke unn ka quran me kitna ilm hai, haaN yeh hoga ke unn se quran parrhna seekha hoga, like every urdu-bacha seekhta hai. aap ne bhi seekha hai, main ne bhi ustani sahiba se seekha hai, magar siraf arbi parrhni, waisay unn se agar kissi lafz ka matlab bhi poochuN to unheN nahi aata hoga. this is light difference. Mirza Ghulam Ahmad (as) ke zamanay me maane hue ustad maujood the, jinn sabb ne aap ki kitaab "baraheen-e-ahmadiyya" ki itni tareefeN ki, bad me magar jabb dawa kiya Masih maud hone ka to wuhi dushman bann gaye. to janab, sabit to abhi aap ne karna hai ke kissi ustad ke shagird the.

aur ab hamare sawalat ka bhi jawab de deN zara. jo pehle bhi kiye aur ab bhi kar dete haiN.

hazrat Isa(as) faut ho gaye ya nahi?
koi ghair-sharii prophet ummat me asakta hai ya nahi?

pehle basics decide kar lijiye, aap ko sabb kuch samajh aajayegi. jabb naali meN phanssa hua pathar ni nikala jaaye uss waqat takk paani aage behta nahi hai, aik hi jaga par kharra reh jata hai. so pathar hatayiye.

Posted 14 Jun 2005

Shahrukh Khan says

Shahrukh Khan

Age: 124
7861 days old here
Total Posts: 43596
Points: 0

Location:
Netherlands, Netherlands

IMAM MEHDI?

Posted 14 Jun 2005

irsa says

irsa

Age: 124
7109 days old here
Total Posts: 1595
Points: 0

Location:
Canada, Canada

shahrukh khan said:
IMAM MEHDI?

twelwe imam

Posted 14 Jun 2005

valandrian says

valandrian

Age: 2023
2427 days old here
Total Posts: 153147
Points: 10

Location:
,

Posted 30 Apr 2018

valandrian says

valandrian

Age: 2023
2427 days old here
Total Posts: 153147
Points: 10

Location:
,

Posted 18 Sep 2018

valandrian says

valandrian

Age: 2023
2427 days old here
Total Posts: 153147
Points: 10

Location:
,

Posted 23 Oct 2018

valandrian says

valandrian

Age: 2023
2427 days old here
Total Posts: 153147
Points: 10

Location:
,

XI 21 CH Be An DV Ju Ge As Co VI Ov Do Sy XV MP XV Ja WM El XX Ka XJ Sa Ro Ju ja II Al Gu
II Gl Vi Cr Di Ur Ah Im Re ww XI Ja Wo Sc Ma IW Ve Pi El Ni mp Ar XI Wi Ab Gi XX De Ex Ro
II Wi Th RA XI XX Aq Fr Po Je XV St Sa Ro IV So Sp Um CD LP Wi Th Ze Ze Lu La Bl Wa Th Pr
DV Pa In Ar Ze XX DV sk Ju Ki Ho Os Go DC Wi Jo XV Fo Ze Wa Ha ks Bi ch Sp Ge XI XX XI DV
Su Vi Ho El Pe Ti Bo Fr DV FU Po Al RX XX Be Pr PR XX Th ja Cl Ed Si Ha Na Di ww Wi Wi Sa
KW Ke Vi Lo Ro Fo XV Jo XX PR Ra IV Fo Ac Bi St VI Jo pr Th Ar Vi Em Jo Ba DV Ma It Bo In
Mo So Su DV Gr Fr CD Th Pa Ar Fa Lo CD Hu Sa II Sw Ae Fr Da VI Ba XI XV Ju Pa Jo DV Ma Da
XX XI Ka XX Dr Bu LP Ri Al Sl Ti As

Posted 11 Nov 2018

vipinkumar says

vipinkumar

Age: 2023
1751 days old here
Total Posts: 5416
Points: 10

Location:
,

There is no doubt that music is the soul of any occasion. In fact, it is the primary thing that adds color to an event. Without good music, you could imagine your event or party as a hectic, boring, and dull thing, especially for the guests. An event that lacks good music can never be enjoyed. Most people would prefer to attend such functions that have a proper arrangement of music. A wedding celebration is no exception at all. To make this day even more special, you should make arrangements for music and for this reason, you could take help from the professional wedding live band In Los Angeles. Here we come into the picture.

MAKE YOUR EVENT THE TALK OF THE TOWN:
Do you want a music band that would set your wedding apart in a true sense? You’ve come to the right place. Divine specializes in incomparable wedding bands, which provide an alternative to the conventional live music experience. Our ultimate aim is to deliver unforgettable, as well as unique entertainment that would keep the dance floor not only full but would leave a long-lasting impression at the same time. Most Bands for Weddings in California are just carbon copies. But don’t forget that you are one-of-a-kind couple hence you deserve a one-of-a-kind musical entertainment for your big day.

Our music bands regularly provide services in the Los Angeles area. We are even pleased to travel to the destination weddings, both international and national. We have performed more than 300 events and weddings that make us a more desirable choice of these days. At Divine, we ensure a one-of-a-kind entertainment experience particularly for one of the most striking days of your life.

TOP-RATED WEDDING BAND:
Divine has years of experience in the industry. Our sound experience makes us the very first call for corporate and wedding entertainment. The expertise and the attention to detail that Divine offers are unparalleled. We understand that selecting the ideal entertainment professional for the special day of your life is important for your event success. And we as a professional pride ourselves in working very closely with each client.

Posted 11 Feb 2020

Reply to Topic

A Questi&#111;n about MGAQ &quot;?&quot;

Search Forum

A Question about MGAQ "?"