mention not .

platonic:

YDAKH is far more impressive movie than LP .

YDAKH was technically very correct , the reason is that some indians assisted sheikh sahab in direction of ydakh , but in LP there are blunders big big blunders .

platonic jee.....altho i have not seen LP, i HAVE seen YDAKH..........and it too, had its lowpoints... BIG lowpoints!

as long as saima delivered a kick-ass performance as she always does, the quality is good, and that one song sung by humaira arshad is nicely picturized....LP will be a hit 4 me!!

so was any of my criteria met?!?!....please inform!

platonic:

Coming to the Positive Points :

After a succesfull criticizing effort now lemme come to the positive aspects of the movie :

1: Sceneries of Malaysia were breath taking , nicely seleted and shooted .

2: Shamil khan has got some cool looks , i heard some gals were talking of him .

3: Set of the Shamil's house was good .

4: Songs were well placed in the movie . They were having proper links with story , here credit goes to the director .

5: Language that Sikhs were speaking was ditto to the actual sikhs , cast was looking to be doing some hard work with the language , saima used to call Shamil , oye shamla , that was really cool .

6 : Acting performance of Saima and Baber was good , Shamil need some hard work but with the passage of time he will learn the things .

PLATONIC bruv !!!

You should have put plus and minus points all on same post !!!

So that their was some balance !!!

I agree with all your plus points except 6 !!!
I felt Shamils perfomance was 1st class !!!

platonic:

Dear whkhan :

U said that u dont agree with most of my points , ok these are my points tell me where i am wrong :

1: Combination of Shamil & Saima . Was that perfect ?

2: Saima's Fitness , age reflection . Is it fine ?

3: Weak Direction > Story Control > Almost half movie was past without having REAL story being begun . Remember Intermission , it came when Baber saw both of them in garden . People in the theatre were dieing to see that scene from last half hour , wernt u ?

4: Weak Direction > Dream Works > Song in which Saima came in Yellow Roofless sports car , not only me but whole crowd was confused either it is another dream or really saima has came to shamil .

5: Weak Direction >Propaganda Against Hindus : I think here we have some misunderstanding , i didnt said/meant that we should not critisize hindus , they should be but with some planning . That part of the story must have a link with some previously occured incidents in the story , friend of baber who just had an introduction and driving scene suddenly became villen , and a big villen , didnt u noticed that .

6: Vulgar ChitChat : Didnt u notice Irfan Khosat and company saying some vulgar sentences , Aisay kaam kiyoon kerti hai jin ki wajah say baar baar nahana perta hai , Mera Lahore choota rah gaya hai , didnt u hear those lines , ya samajh he nahin aa rahi thi , ohhhhh sh*tt i was watching the movie with my Female CFs , yaar sach main i was feeling shame when that part of the movie was on . My whole academy class was with me and we all were down .

In The End I would like to say that give proper arguments to clear your points , be realistic , apni baat ko properly explain karo , your comment that its the best movie in Pak history gives an idea that u r trying to start a useless behaas baray behaas situation , fazool behaas ka faida na aap ka ho ga ne mera , na Lollywood ka aur na JB ka .

PLATONIC - Here is my opinion !!!

1 - Not perfect - but it worked , they look like a couple .

2 - Saima looks better in LP than any of her other films
slim , tall and pretty ( not beautifull ) .

3 - Weak direction - strongly disagree - althoug first half was bit slow .

4 - disagree I didn't find it confusing - I didn't think it was a dream .

5 - I agree hindu bashing wasn't necassary , we don't need to follow bollysh*t example .

6 - I haven't got a clue what you are talking about - I watched it with my family without a problem .

Thanks thats all !!!

hows the buisnees of the film in pak then

shahrukh khan:

slim?????????? tall???????????? << wide screen ya good couple boy en woman.

Wait till you see the movie !!!