PLATONIC
Age: 43
7777 days old here
Total Posts: 1098
Points: 0
Location:
lahore, Pakistan
Coming to the Positive Points :
After a succesfull criticizing effort now lemme come to the positive aspects of the movie :
1: Sceneries of Malaysia were breath taking , nicely seleted and shooted .
2: Shamil khan has got some cool looks , i heard some gals were talking of him .
3: Set of the Shamil's house was good .
4: Songs were well placed in the movie . They were having proper links with story , here credit goes to the director .
5: Language that Sikhs were speaking was ditto to the actual sikhs , cast was looking to be doing some hard work with the language , saima used to call Shamil , oye shamla , that was really cool .
6 : Acting performance of Saima and Baber was good , Shamil need some hard work but with the passage of time he will learn the things .
PLATONIC
Age: 43
7777 days old here
Total Posts: 1098
Points: 0
Location:
lahore, Pakistan
Dear whkhan :
U said that u dont agree with most of my points , ok these are my points tell me where i am wrong :
1: Combination of Shamil & Saima . Was that perfect ?
2: Saima's Fitness , age reflection . Is it fine ?
3: Weak Direction > Story Control > Almost half movie was past without having REAL story being begun . Remember Intermission , it came when Baber saw both of them in garden . People in the theatre were dieing to see that scene from last half hour , wernt u ?
4: Weak Direction > Dream Works > Song in which Saima came in Yellow Roofless sports car , not only me but whole crowd was confused either it is another dream or really saima has came to shamil .
5: Weak Direction >Propaganda Against Hindus : I think here we have some misunderstanding , i didnt said/meant that we should not critisize hindus , they should be but with some planning . That part of the story must have a link with some previously occured incidents in the story , friend of baber who just had an introduction and driving scene suddenly became villen , and a big villen , didnt u noticed that .
6: Vulgar ChitChat : Didnt u notice Irfan Khosat and company saying some vulgar sentences , Aisay kaam kiyoon kerti hai jin ki wajah say baar baar nahana perta hai , Mera Lahore choota rah gaya hai , didnt u hear those lines , ya samajh he nahin aa rahi thi , ohhhhh sh*tt i was watching the movie with my Female CFs , yaar sach main i was feeling shame when that part of the movie was on . My whole academy class was with me and we all were down .
In The End I would like to say that give proper arguments to clear your points , be realistic , apni baat ko properly explain karo , your comment that its the best movie in Pak history gives an idea that u r trying to start a useless behaas baray behaas situation , fazool behaas ka faida na aap ka ho ga ne mera , na Lollywood ka aur na JB ka .platonic37991.162037037
PLATONIC
Age: 43
7777 days old here
Total Posts: 1098
Points: 0
Location:
lahore, Pakistan
YDAKH : Meray betay , i told u that neither i watch Paki movies regularly nor indian , i didnt say that i havnt ever watched any single paki movie . As far as influence from indi movies is concerned , ok dont compare the acting or direction of paki movies with indi movies , compare the class of your tv dramas with your own films , doodh ka doodh aur pani ka pani , i never said that pakis dont know how to make movies , if you see Urdu movies of late 70s to mid 80s , when nadeem , babra , shabnam and other paki actors were in , movies used to be shoot in nepal srilanka ,turkey those movies were best . Coming to the point Hindu /Muslim , I didnt mean that there shouldnt be any critisism on hindus or other anti-islam elements , yes they should be highlighted , but with a proper way , take an example of LOC whole movie is against Us , pakistanis , whole movie was designed for that very purpose , but here the hindu part was not well planned , it was looking like a cherry on the cake not having any link with the story , farz he poora kia hua tha , i tell u one very interesting fact , at the time of Partition these were sikhs who did 75% of the massacre against migrating muslims , now we call them our brothers , but we have to as they are also anti hindus , anyway such movies with a lil big budget good quality cameras , nice music are far more better than those of Gundasa movies .
PLATONIC
Age: 43
7777 days old here
Total Posts: 1098
Points: 0
Location:
lahore, Pakistan
YDAKH is far more impressive movie than LP .
YDAKH was technically very correct , the reason is that some indians assisted sheikh sahab in direction of ydakh , but in LP there are blunders big big blunders .
PLATONIC
Age: 43
7777 days old here
Total Posts: 1098
Points: 0
Location:
lahore, Pakistan
whkhan1 :
have u seen the movie , if yes ! tell me where i am wrong ! I can bet any guy who have seen the movie will agree with me . I have used the words very carefully and have suggested the soloution where it was possible , dont know where we have clash of observation .
YDAKH : Yaar if i dont see the movies i dosnt mean i dont know what i shown in our movies or what quality of content these movies are having ? As far as ~dubba~ is concerned , i used that term just to explain the extract that i got from the movie , every one knows a film which is not impressive is called DUBBA , so if i have used this term , then what ?
PLATONIC
Age: 43
7777 days old here
Total Posts: 1098
Points: 0
Location:
lahore, Pakistan
MERAY PASS ITNA TIME HO TO MAIN LOC KAY DUSRAY PART KA SCRIPT LIKH DOON ! ANYWAYS U R WALKING ON A VERY THIN LINE TRY TO BE METICULOUS , OR U GET SOME THRASHING FROM FFM !
Indian Army 
